The Failure Pledge

Politics

Next

Winston Churchill

Winston Churchill

What failed

He lost his first parliamentary contest in 1899. In 1915 the Dardanelles campaign, his project, failed badly enough to cost him the Admiralty; excluded from the new War Committee that November, he resigned from government and went to the trenches. He lost Dundee in 1922, Leicester West in 1923, and the Westminster Abbey by-election in 1924 by forty-three votes. Then came the Wilderness Years: out of office, isolated over India, and beaten 386 to 122 when his five-year campaign against Indian self-government finally reached a vote. He was shouted down in the Commons in 1936, and on 6 October 1938, the day after he told the House that Britain had sustained 'a total and unmitigated defeat' at Munich, the Commons approved the settlement by 366 votes to 144. Churchill remained seated and abstained rather than vote against his own party.

What happened next

Nineteen months after the Commons approved the Munich settlement over his objections, he became Prime Minister.

The point

The famous poster says he failed sixth grade. He did not — he finished near the top of his class at Sandhurst, and the Churchill Society calls the dunce story a myth he encouraged himself. The real record is a man who was wrong in public, out of office, and out of favour for most of a decade, which is a far more useful thing to know.

The sequence

9 documented failures, shown with the successes in between. Every entry carries its own source — the wins are part of the record, and leaving them out is how these stories get distorted.

  1. 1899

    He loses his first parliamentary contest, finishing third of four.

    failureChurchill General Election and By-Election Results (Hillsdale College)

  2. 1915

    The Dardanelles campaign fails and costs him the Admiralty.

    failureFranco-British naval attack on Dardanelles fails (International Churchill Society)

  3. 1915

    Left off the new War Committee, he resigns from government altogether and goes to the front.

    failureAutumn 1915 (International Churchill Society)

  4. 1922

    He loses his seat at Dundee, finishing fourth.

    failureChurchill's Elections (International Churchill Society)

  5. 1923

    He loses again, at Leicester West.

    failureChurchill's Elections (International Churchill Society)

  6. 1924

    He loses the Westminster Abbey by-election by forty-three votes.

    failure1924 Westminster Abbey by-election (Wikipedia)

  7. 1930s

    Out of office, isolated, and widely considered finished.

    failureWinston Churchill in the 1930s (International Churchill Society)

  8. 1935

    His five-year campaign against Indian self-government is beaten 386 to 122.

    failureGovernment of India Bill, HC Deb 5 June 1935 (Hansard, UK Parliament)

  9. 1938

    The Commons approves the Munich settlement by 366 to 144; Churchill abstains.

    failurePolicy of His Majesty's Government, HC Deb 6 October 1938 (Hansard, UK Parliament)

  10. 1940

    He becomes Prime Minister.

    successSir Winston Churchill (GOV.UK)

Sources

Use the and keys to move between entries.

← All of them