The Failure Pledge

Actor

Next

Susan Lucci

Susan Lucci in a red dress at a Heart Truth event.
Ten years after the streak ended.

What failed

Eighteen times she sat in an audience with a camera on her face and heard another name. Her surname became the generic term for a perpetual runner-up, and she made a television advert about it herself.

What happened next

She kept accepting the nomination. On the nineteenth, in May 1999, the presenter opened the envelope and said the streak was over.

The point

Most failure runs are private, which is what makes them survivable. Lucci's was broadcast annually. She turned up for the nineteenth knowing exactly how the first eighteen had gone.

The sequence

3 documented failures, shown with the successes in between. Every entry carries its own source — the wins are part of the record, and leaving them out is how these stories get distorted.

  1. 1978

    First Daytime Emmy nomination for Erica Kane. She loses.

    failureSusan Lucci (Wikipedia)

  2. 1981-1998

    Seventeen more nominations, seventeen more losses.

    failureSusan Lucci (Wikipedia)

  3. 1989

    Eleven years in, she films a commercial about the drought.

    noteSusan Lucci (Wikipedia)

  4. 1999

    Nominated a nineteenth time, still without a win.

    failure19th Emmy Nod For Lucci (CBS News, 11 March 1999)

  5. 1999

    She wins, on the nineteenth nomination, at the 26th Daytime Emmy Awards.

    success26th Daytime Emmy Awards (Wikipedia)

Sources

Use the and keys to move between entries.

← All of them