The Failure Pledge

Painter

Next

Frida Kahlo

Frida Kahlo

What failed

She was reading natural sciences at the National Preparatory School in Mexico City, intending to become a physician, when a streetcar hit her bus on 17 September 1925 and an iron handrail went through her pelvis. It displaced three vertebrae, put her in hospital for a month and confined her to bed in a plaster corset for the better part of three months, and it ended the medical career. She began painting in oils during the recovery. For most of the next two decades the painting did not pay: she would not adapt her style to what buyers wanted, she left one Mexican government commission unfinished, and the commissioning body rejected the next one. Her first solo exhibition was at the Julien Levy Gallery in New York in 1938, arranged by André Breton, and she sold half of the twenty-five paintings in it. The Paris show that followed in 1939 opened only after she arrived to find that Breton had booked no gallery and had not got her paintings out of customs. Her first solo exhibition in Mexico came in April 1953, staged by Lola Álvarez Bravo because Álvarez Bravo understood she did not have long to live; her doctors had prescribed bed rest, so she had her own four-poster bed moved from her house to the gallery and arrived in an ambulance. Her right leg was amputated at the knee in August 1953 and she died on 13 July 1954, aged forty-seven, known largely as Diego Rivera's wife.

What happened next

The work stayed relatively unknown for more than twenty years after her death. She gained recognition only in the late 1970s, when feminist scholars began reopening the canon and the Chicano movement took her up as one of its icons. The first two books about her were published in Mexico in 1976 and 1977, and in 1977 The Tree of Hope Stands Firm became the first Kahlo painting sold at auction, at $19,000. The first two retrospectives followed in 1978, at the Palacio de Bellas Artes in Mexico City and the Museum of Contemporary Art in Chicago; a joint retrospective with Tina Modotti opened at the Whitechapel Gallery in London in May 1982, and Hayden Herrera's biography appeared in 1983. By 1984 Mexico had declared her works part of the national cultural heritage and banned their export. In November 2025 her 1940 self-portrait El sueño (La cama) sold at Sotheby's in New York for $54.7 million, the most expensive work by a woman artist at auction, seventy-one years after she died.

The point

The record holds two things the myth keeps only one of. She did sell paintings while she was alive, and the first of them went nine years before the New York show: Dos Mujeres was bought directly from her in 1929. Edward G. Robinson took four in the summer of 1938, half the twenty-five in her first solo exhibition sold that year, and a state prize of 5,000 pesos followed in 1946. She also could not make a living from the work until she was close to forty, was refused by the body that commissioned her, and was known in her own lifetime mainly as the wife of a more famous painter and as an eccentric personality among the international cultural elite. The recognition that made her name arrived between twenty-three and thirty years after her death, through auction rooms, feminist art history and the Chicano movement, none of which she arranged.

The sequence

9 documented failures, shown with the successes in between. Every entry carries its own source — the wins are part of the record, and leaving them out is how these stories get distorted.

  1. 1913

    Contracted polio at six; her right leg grew shorter and thinner than the left.

    failureFrida Kahlo (Wikipedia)

  2. 1922

    Accepted to the elite National Preparatory School in Mexico City, studying natural sciences to become a physician.

    successFrida Kahlo (Wikipedia)

  3. 1925

    Working as a paid engraving apprentice, she was not thinking about art as a career at all.

    noteFrida Kahlo (Wikipedia)

  4. 1925

    On 17 September a streetcar hit the bus she was riding home from school. An iron handrail went through her pelvis.

    failureFrida Kahlo (Wikipedia)

  5. 1925

    A month in hospital, three displaced vertebrae, and three months of bed rest in a plaster corset. The medical career was over.

    failureFrida Kahlo (Wikipedia)

  6. 1925

    Started painting in oils during the recovery.

    noteFrida Kahlo - Artist Profile, National Museum of Women in the Arts

  7. 1929

    Sold her first painting, Dos Mujeres, straight out of the studio to an American buyer. She was twenty-two.

    successMFA Boston acquires Dos Mujeres (Salvadora y Herminia)

  8. 1934

    Back in Mexico City she made no new paintings at all, and only two the following year.

    failureFrida Kahlo (Wikipedia)

  9. 1938

    First significant sale: Edward G. Robinson bought four paintings at $200 each.

    successFrida Kahlo (Wikipedia)

  10. 1938

    Her first solo exhibition, arranged by André Breton at the Julien Levy Gallery in New York.

    successFrida Kahlo (Wikipedia)

  11. 1938

    In the middle of the Depression, half the paintings in it sold.

    successFrida Kahlo (Wikipedia)

  12. 1939

    Arrived in Paris for the show Breton had promised, to find he had booked no gallery and her paintings were still stuck in customs.

    failureThe Friendship That Transformed Frida Kahlo - Hyperallergic

  13. 1939

    The Paris exhibition Mexique went ahead at Renou et Colle, which produced a catalogue Levy had not.

    noteAn excerpt from Frida Kahlo's Month in Paris - Yale University Press

  14. 1939

    The French state bought The Frame out of the less successful Paris show. The sources disagree about who acquired it: Wikipedia and Britannica give the standard account that the Louvre bought it, while the Centre Pompidou, which holds the work, records a state purchase in 1939 under the inventory number JP 929 P — the JP prefix being the Musée du Jeu de Paume, then the museum of foreign schools.

    disputed"The Frame" ("Le cadre") - Centre Pompidou collection record

  15. 1939

    Granted a divorce from Diego Rivera in November.

    failureFrida Kahlo (Wikipedia)

  16. 1940s

    Two Mexican government commissions came to nothing: she left the first unfinished and the second was rejected.

    failureFrida Kahlo (Wikipedia)

  17. 1943

    Took a teaching post at the art school La Esmeralda in Mexico City.

    successFrida Kahlo (Wikipedia)

  18. 1945

    Travelled to New York in June for a spinal fusion with a bone graft and steel support; the operation failed.

    failureFrida Kahlo (Wikipedia)

  19. 1946

    Won a 5,000-peso national prize for Moses; the Museo de Arte Moderno bought The Two Fridas the next year.

    successFrida Kahlo (Wikipedia)

  20. 1953

    First solo exhibition in Mexico, staged in April by Lola Álvarez Bravo, who knew Kahlo had little time left. Ordered to stay in bed, she had her own four-poster bed carried from her house to the gallery and arrived in an ambulance.

    successFrida Kahlo (Wikipedia)

  21. 1953

    Her right leg was amputated at the knee in August.

    failureFrida Kahlo (Wikipedia)

  22. 1954

    Died on 13 July, aged forty-seven.

    noteFrida Kahlo (Wikipedia)

  23. 1977

    Twenty-three years after her death, the first Kahlo painting reached auction, fetching $19,000 at Sotheby's.

    noteFrida Kahlo (Wikipedia)

  24. 1978

    The first two retrospectives of her work opened, in Mexico City and Chicago.

    successFrida Kahlo (Wikipedia)

  25. 1984

    Thirty years after her death, Mexico declared her works part of the national cultural heritage and banned their export.

    noteFrida Kahlo (Wikipedia)

  26. 2025

    Her 1940 self-portrait El sueño (La cama) sold for $54.7m at Sotheby's, the highest auction price for any work by a woman.

    successFrida Kahlo painting sells for $54.7m, breaking record for female artists - Al Jazeera

Sources

Use the and keys to move between entries.

← All of them