The Failure Pledge

Invention

Next

Garrett Morgan

Garrett Morgan

What failed

He left home at fourteen with six years of schooling and paid a tutor out of a handyman's wages. He arrived in Cleveland sweeping floors for five dollars a week. He sold his first invention, a belt fastener for sewing machines, outright for a hundred and fifty dollars. An employer told him to end his relationship with the woman he would marry, who was white, or be fired; he quit, and her family had her excommunicated. Then he built a breathing hood that saved lives and could not sell it, because buyers would not deal with a Black inventor.

What happened next

In 1914 he hired a white actor to pose as the inventor while he performed the demonstrations himself under an alias. It worked: the hood won a first prize, fire departments ordered it, and on 25 July 1916 he used it to bring men alive out of a gas-filled tunnel under Lake Erie. The papers reporting the rescue the next day left him out, and Southern cities cancelled their orders once his race was known. In 1923 he sold his traffic signal patent to General Electric for forty thousand dollars.

The point

The usual telling is that nobody would buy his invention. The record is worse and more precise: it sold well, but only after he had hidden himself behind an actor and a false name. The failure was never the product.

The sequence

7 documented failures, shown with the successes in between. Every entry carries its own source — the wins are part of the record, and leaving them out is how these stories get distorted.

  1. 1891

    He leaves home at fourteen with six years of schooling, and pays a tutor out of a handyman's wages.

    failureOf courage and caution (USPTO)

  2. 1895

    He arrives in Cleveland sweeping floors for five dollars a week.

    failureOf courage and caution (USPTO)

  3. 1901

    He sells his first invention outright for a hundred and fifty dollars.

    failureInventor Garrett Morgan, Cleveland's Fierce Bootstrapper, by Margaret Bernstein (Teaching Cleveland Digital)

  4. 1907

    His employer tells him to end his relationship or be fired. He quits.

    failureOf courage and caution (USPTO)

  5. 1914

    After repeated failed attempts to sell it, he hires a white actor to pose as the inventor.

    failureBlack Inventor Garrett Morgan Saved Countless Lives (Scientific American)

  6. 1916

    On 25 July he goes into the gas-filled tunnel under Lake Erie in his own hood, rescues two men alive and brings out four bodies.

    successWaterworks Tunnel Disasters (Encyclopedia of Cleveland History, Case Western Reserve University)

  7. 1916

    The papers reporting the rescue the next day leave him out.

    failureBlack Inventor Garrett Morgan Saved Countless Lives (Scientific American)

  8. 1916

    Southern cities cancel their orders once they learn the inventor is Black.

    failureOf courage and caution (USPTO)

  9. 1923

    He sells his traffic signal patent to General Electric for forty thousand dollars.

    successMorgan, Garrett A. (Encyclopedia of Cleveland History, Case Western Reserve University)

Sources

Use the and keys to move between entries.

← All of them